Insurance Company Tactics: How Insurers Delay, Deny, and Devalue Claims

The Short Answer…

When you file a claim after an accident, insurance companies often use tactics to protect their bottom line rather than pay you fairly. These strategies—sometimes called the “3 D’s” (Delay, Deny, Defend)—are designed to minimize payouts, frustrate victims, and pressure people into unfair settlements. Other common tactics include misrepresenting policy language, demanding excessive documentation, disputing necessary medical treatment, misleading you about deadlines, or even conducting surveillance to try and discredit your claim.

To protect yourself, keep detailed records of every communication, avoid giving recorded statements without advice, and work with a knowledgeable personal injury lawyer who understands how insurers operate and can fight for fair compensation.

Get Your Free Case Review

Key Takeaways

• Insurance companies delay on purpose: They often stall investigations or request unnecessary paperwork to wear you down.
• Lowball settlements are common: Quick, small offers are used to get victims to accept less than they may deserve.
• Adjusters may twist your words: Recorded statements and medical authorizations can be used against you.
• Medical treatment is often disputed: Insurers claim your injuries aren’t as severe or aren’t related to the accident.
• Legal help levels the playing field: An attorney can counter these tactics and pursue full and fair compensation.

1. Recorded Statements

Adjusters may try to call you on a recorded line and get you to say something they can later use to weaken your claim. Even seemingly harmless comments can be twisted to suggest you’re not as injured as you claim or that you admitted fault.

2. Medical Authorization & Pre-Existing Conditions

Insurers may push you to sign broad medical authorizations so they can search for pre-existing conditions and argue your injuries aren’t accident-related. This tactic allows them to shift blame away from the accident and reduce the potential payout.

3. Misrepresentation of the Law and Your Coverage

Adjusters sometimes misstate what damages you can seek or claim that there’s less coverage available than the policy actually provides. By confusing you about your legal rights, they hope you’ll accept less money than the policy truly allows.

4. Denying Liability & Blaming You

Another classic move is to deny responsibility altogether or claim you were partially at fault. Insurers may claim that you caused or contributed to the accident, which reduces or eliminates their obligation to pay and can shift the burden of proof onto you.

5. Denying or Undervaluing Claims Without Proper Review

Some insurers deny coverage prematurely or accept liability but still minimize damages like pain, suffering, or future medical care. This forces victims into a position where they must fight harder just to get the compensation they may be legally entitled to.

6. Disputing or Downplaying Injuries

Whether by hiring defense medical experts, disputing bills, or “nickel-and-diming” individual charges, insurers often attempt to minimize the severity and cost of your injuries. This tactic can make it harder for you to recover full compensation for long-term care and future medical needs.

7. Disputing Medical Treatment

Insurers often argue that certain treatments are unnecessary or unrelated to your accident, even if you are trying to follow your doctor’s recommendations. They may even send you to a biased “independent” medical examiner who downplays your injuries.

8. Misinterpreting Policy Language

Policies are written in complex legal jargon. Adjusters may misrepresent coverage limits or exclusions, making you believe you’re entitled to less than you actually are.

9. Delay Tactics

Known as one of the “3 D’s,” insurance company delay tactics are used to stretch out the claims process. Adjusters may repeatedly request unnecessary documentation, fail to return your calls, or prolong the investigation in hopes you’ll accept a smaller settlement or give up entirely.

10. Excessive Documentation Requests

By demanding unnecessary paperwork, adjusters create deliberate delays and frustration. The goal is to wear you down until you either give up or agree to settle for less.

11. Pressure & Misleading Deadlines

Companies may push quick settlements with false urgency or claim your filing deadline has already passed. This scare tactic is designed to make you act hastily instead of taking the time to evaluate the true value of your claim.

12. Lowball Settlement Offers

Quick, low offers are one of the most recognizable insurance adjuster tactics. They try to tempt you with “fast money” before you fully understand your medical costs, lost wages, and long-term damages.

13. Confusion, Coercion & Friendly Tactics

Adjusters may use complicated legal jargon, act overly sympathetic, or pretend to be on your side to gain your trust and then undermine your case. By appearing helpful, they hope you’ll share information or agree to terms that ultimately hurt your claim.

14. Surveillance and Social Media Monitoring

It’s not uncommon for insurance companies to monitor your social media or even hire investigators. If they catch you doing something that seems inconsistent with your injuries, they’ll use it against you.

15. Allegations of Fraud

Sometimes, insurers go so far as to accuse victims of exaggerating injuries or inflating costs as another way to deny or devalue valid claims.

16. Refusing to Negotiate in Good Faith

Some adjusters simply stonewall, offering little or nothing meaningful to wear you down. This unfair strategy often pushes victims into lengthy disputes or litigation just to secure what should have been paid in the first place.

17. Discouraging You From Hiring an Attorney

One of the most damaging insurance company bad faith tactics is telling you that hiring a lawyer will only complicate things. In reality, this benefits the insurance company, not you. An experienced attorney can step in to protect your rights, handle negotiations on your behalf, and help make sure you don’t fall victim to unfair settlement practices.

Get Your Free Case Review

The “3 D’s” of Insurance: Delay, Deny, Defend

Many adjusters operate on the 3 D’s principle:

• Delay: Stall the claim until the victim becomes desperate.
• Deny: Reject coverage, often without proper investigation.
• Defend: Take the case to court and use aggressive legal defenses to reduce or eliminate payout.

Recognizing this pattern helps you understand why your claim may feel like an uphill battle. These tactics are not accidents—they are part of a well-planned strategy designed to protect the insurer’s bottom line, not your recovery.

How to Protect Yourself Against Insurance Adjuster Delay Tactics

Insurance companies count on the fact that most people don’t know how to push back against their strategies. The more you understand their delay tactics, the better prepared you are to protect your rights and keep your claim moving forward.

Here are some practical steps you can take:

• Don’t sign anything right away: Avoid signing medical authorizations or releases without legal advice.
• Be careful with recorded statements: You are not required to provide one without a lawyer present.
• Keep detailed records: Document every interaction with the insurance company.
• Consult with an attorney early: A lawyer can spot unfair tactics and push back.

How Our Lawyers Fight Back Against Insurance Company Tactics

At Stewart Bell, PLLC, we know every insurance company tactic designed to undermine your claim because we’ve been fighting and winning against them for decades. Our West Virginia personal injury lawyers have built a reputation in Charleston, Huntington, Dunbar, and across the state for standing up to powerful insurance companies and leveling the playing field for injured victims.

Here’s how we can help you:

• Spot bad faith right away: We quickly identify delay tactics, lowball offers, and other unfair strategies before they can hurt your claim.
• Fight for maximum compensation: Our team negotiates aggressively to make sure you’re not pressured into settling for less than you may be entitled to.
• Build the strongest case possible: We work with medical experts, investigators, and accident specialists to prove the true extent of your injuries and losses.
• Take insurers to court if needed: Because we prepare every case for trial, insurance companies know we’re serious about securing justice.

Insurance companies have entire teams of lawyers and adjusters working against you. With Stewart Bell on your side, you gain a dedicated law firm that knows the local courts, understands the community, and won’t back down until you receive the compensation you may be entitled to.

Get Your Free Case Review

Don’t Let Unfair Insurance Practices Stand in Your Way

Insurance companies use every trick in the book to minimize or deny valid claims, but you don’t have to face them alone. By understanding common insurance company tactics and working with an experienced personal injury lawyer, you can protect your rights and fight for fair compensation.

At Stewart Bell, PLLC, we know how insurers operate, and we’re ready to push back on your behalf. Whether it’s delaying your claim, making a lowball offer, or disputing your medical treatment, our team is here to stand up for you.

Contact us today for a free consultation and let us help you fight back against unfair insurance tactics.